A Facebook post made by Balen Shah nearly four years ago has returned to the spotlight after Nepal's Supreme Court released the full text of its judgment on the controversial garbage collection halt at major government offices.
On Chait 25, 2079 BS, then-Kathmandu Mayor Balen Shah announced that garbage collection at Singha Durbar would stop, accusing the Pushpa Kamal Dahal 'Prachanda'-led federal government of failing to cooperate on waste management. Garbage collection was subsequently halted at Singha Durbar, Shital Niwas and Baluwatar, leading to a legal challenge in the Supreme Court.
The court has now criticized Kathmandu Metropolitan City's decision, describing the suspension of garbage collection over disagreements with the federal government as legally and constitutionally immature and impractical. It emphasized that political disputes cannot justify disrupting essential sanitation services or compromising citizens' constitutional right to a clean and healthy environment.
However, the court did not criticize only the metropolitan city's actions. It also strongly criticized the federal government's failure to provide necessary cooperation and coordination, stating that obstructing waste management or neglecting responsibilities toward local governments was unacceptable.
To prevent similar disputes, the Supreme Court issued 11 directives to government authorities and Kathmandu Metropolitan City. These include introducing mandatory waste segregation guidelines, increasing recycling, requiring producers to take responsibility for packaging waste, improving Banchare Danda landfill infrastructure, fulfilling commitments to affected residents, ensuring security for garbage transportation and providing funding for local waste management facilities.
The directives also call for promoting waste-to-energy projects, raising public awareness, strengthening cooperation between different levels of government and establishing better waste management laws and monitoring systems.
Interestingly, the Supreme Court dismissed the original petition because garbage collection had already resumed following an interim court order. Nevertheless, it issued broader directives to ensure that similar disagreements do not interrupt essential public services in the future.
The case hearing concluded on Poush 21, 2082 BS, and the full judgment came into public attention on Mangsir 1, 2083 BS.
The ruling revisits a major controversy from Balen Shah's time as Kathmandu mayor, while reminding both local and federal authorities that political disagreements must not come at the cost of essential services.